0 0Y~Nmf[[_N
N TvSU\-NV[yr[vSSTeS O~S[
N Tvlh_0Bl@b gV[u_ T Nlh_Sc#:Nev ^V;NIN_`T N*NNb:N-N_ve O~p0YV[vSU\~ wegb~N*Nc#0 NNV[ YTT1 9 4 9 1 9 7 9 t^v-NV V!jND,g;NIN]NS
ND,g;NINvl_SO|TNCg~g ~g1Y%N0vQNV[ YS~nTWS (W1 9 8 0 t^N+gNMRV!jND,g;NINl_SO6RTNCg~g
Nl;N?elSO6R (W1 9 8 0 t^N+gNNa0R7hL
N g~_N _YT[?el;Nvlh0e,gNVT_V!jNNhQ萄vD,g;NINl_0?elT~Nm6R^ FOOYuN)YvvyrCg0(W:ON[)YvCgR6Rav`Q N [S_N^8^bRv~NmSU\0c Neg[SRNNb Oeu-NVTvQNV[ ~e,gN0-NVNTvQNN2mN&^eg~p0sSO(WVQ `S N/cdlullhKN_ e,gN6qOYuNgNsQe?e^TONsQ|vN2mNL:NQR0(W1 9 9 0 t^Ne,gvёqS:g6R Np0 0
0 0@b gN~hf X[(W N*N6R^8h_ [/f gbRv~NmSU\v9h,g0Vdk lh/f_>yO;NINV[v6R^ThQtD,g;NIN6R^ Tv z
N/fR N*N,g(
N
N TeD,g;NINv6R^Re z ( S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 ) 0
0 0-NVvSh6R/f:ON[?ey^v^:W[T9eivNh0-NVv[l ( h t t p : / / w w w . q u i s . n e t / c h i n a l a w ) (W~qQNZQN?elWeCg b~RCgTCgR6RavclI{ebNvQN>yO;NINv[lv
N)Y
N/fegQY~Tlv Tav wlv
yO;NIN6R[N NWYyr[vh0Vdk [fP N*N 0-NVN gPlQS
0vz z0,{N (W-NVv[l l gsQelQOYUOybQ[lvag>k0[l g~QlQl`HNSNv^ Ta7hq_Tmv N*Nvhvc:y01\N uNsQe-NV[lvTl'`0 g_ @b glQlCg)R/f1uV[TZQ~~~v FOV[TZQ~~[CgRvWeeg 0
N)Y
0- - 0lR;NINTkl N ``vab_`
0
N ckS_vt1u0Vdk v&O ( P i l o n , 1 9 9 8 , p . 3 5 5 ) y-NVv[l:N 0BleP?e^v N*N~
00 0
0 00RvMR (W-NVl gS[[lv gq_TR -NVNlvqS:g a
N Y:_p QR
N-NVv]'Y!j hf[?eRlhvSR*Y\ Vdk -NVv^:W[T9eiS(WqQNZQ8nbRv <{[s0N 9eiZQ~~ve_)Rv@b cc1\
N:N*`N0 0
0 0R6R[0N0gbLTSN/fNv TvZQ~~@b[cNS6R^SNvV[:gO;NIN vQBlZQv)Rv
N`zrrr>yOvy)R0V[:gO;NINS1u?e^[yNONeQLNvc6RTV[c:YyNON:NOf0-NV g N*N
NAQyNONNNvLNh0NLNSbLN0?eT5uON00*zz0Oi0**Y]N0wS00QHr0ybSN0eSvQ[LN0(W NAS*NLNKNY yNONP6RNNNAS*NLN Sb}lf6R 5uP[Y0e8nNtI{ ( H u a n g , 1 9 9 3 , P 8 8 ) SY VE8f0ybST.UAmQ QHrSYvQNLNvPSvS6R^mdNyNONvY g)RSV:gO v^N uNNVTvQNSV[v8fQz0yr+R0W gCgS>eSv?e^:gg(WS3u\OvLN ge_)Rv0OY VE8fvS1uY~8萁S [/f-NVv_Y'Y8flQSv@b g0ybST.UAmQvS/f1ub g0WeV gAmQv0We?e^YXTO@bS S_6q S>eSvSR/fBl?e^:ggvWe)Rv0 0
0 0*R ( M u e l l e r , 1 9 9 8 ) }N5uO蕄vV[We[~NmSU\v bq_T yWehf*NLNvR6R[0;NSN0gbLRvN/f T NV g~~0V V[:gO;NIN6R^S ~NmSU\S0R;x0-NV g N*N^8^PSvbzONv?e^ybQ6R^ dNwmWSwNY el glQSv1uT%Y _Nl glQSvR{v ( 1 9 9 9 P e i , 1 9 9 8 ) gfkevN~8^gvbzONvlQD,gBl0 T7bM|6R^0OO?bTLNvV[We cONY(ueBlV[:gO;NINv gHec6Rel0v&O ( P i l o n , 1 9 9 8 ) cQ @b gvGPlQNmyS_6q-NV[lvW,g8nbR@b/ec0 0
0 0V[c:YyNON _Ye1 9 5 0 t^Ne gv?elR }vI{N ( B a i , e t a l , 1 9 9 9 ) :N (W9eit^N[~~X[(W0 N*Nc~X[(WvSV/f (W?e^Q萄vCgReNTab_`vb-N [yNONab_`
Nvgk0}vI{N(ueNf (W9eieNV[c:YL:NvS Nyb__/f6eeQc:Y
N TB\!kv?e^>PTe:_RTyz9NNNNvON{Cg+eS=\SYvS[6eeQ0 Ny1 9 8 8 t^[wy%ONvxvzSs zTDR9R(W Nw\SpS[ON)Rmv6 3 % S_NASy
N Tv6e9{S_ zR buf07hvzR bO_y%ONdNwNfT6eeQegz9NY N uX[0( -NV~Nmt^t 1 9 8 9 P 1 0 7 ) 0ASt^N_ Ny1 9 9 8 t^[_wy%ONvxvzbJT YNTv;`)Rm'Y~/f;`6eeQv1 0 % Te;`vz9Rweg1 0 % :_R~ N[y%ONv6e9 g5 0 Yy N6e9v NNy{|/f?e^]S^vagOTR@bybkv0yxvz_Q~
N`sQvQONv@b g dNw6eeQzY+Re b0QQgvQl/fYz9v;NS[ te*N9ei g ?e^[Ql\ONQ\R"}'`_6eTa_zvepe 6q R"}'`_6eTa_zNe_nfM0(W NN0We TQl"}S6 1 y
N T{|Wv6e90 ( N %N hg;N 1 9 9 5 ) -NV 1 9 9 0 t^N _Y!jNe_vl_ FO/f(WqQN;NINv[?eR N Nl_ Y 1 9 9 4 t^v
0T Tl 0 1 9 9 3 t^v
0S
NckS_zNl 0
N/{_gbL0 hg ( 1 9 9 8 ) yr+Rc0RN
0lQSl 0TqQN;NINv[?eRv
Nv['` *R ( M u e l l e r , 1 9 9 8 , P 2 0 0 ) yr+Rc0R5uOLNvV[WeN
0S
NckS_zNl 0KNv
Nv['` SN N~ Y[e_l_v!jN(WqQN;NINv[?eR N
N\O0[?ev~_ghf-NVv9eiSlWSh6RMR ye_N uv gNN_S[NpNyrCg6B\e_)Rvvw g}YY bN\(uQ*NOP[f Np0 0
0 04 . 2 -NVvQQg9eiT W0W6R^
0 0,{ N*NOP[/f-NVvQQg9eiT W0W6R^ ( Y a n g , W a n g , W i l l s , 1 9 9 2 ; S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 , P 3 0 ; W u , 1 9 9 8 ) (W-NVvQQg9ei QglSO@b gv W0WO(uCg(W7 0 t^N+gR~NQl0 (W 1 9 8 0 t^N, W0WvQ.U[hQybk, =\{N1 9 8 4 t^w ]~AQ W0WO(uCgl( Y a n g , W a n g , W i l l s 1 9 9 2 P 1 8 ) Qgr^9hncQg^NSvSSc6R W0WveRM0Dehf (WQN9eive g QN蕄v1uST[ g W0Wv[^bS#N6RN uNNNwv N!k'`vQN uNsc0 N*N{USvYc{hf 1 9 7 8 t^QN9eiO4l;zT\Nb`
YN[N1 9 5 4 1 9 7 7 t^SOS@bS6Rv\o(WXR ( SOS(W1 9 5 0 t^R (W1 9 5 8 t^~pv'Y0Rv\) 0 wQSO O(u1 9 5 2 - 5 7 t^ gNvXs 1 9 8 2 - 9 1 t^4l;zT\vN4ls^=(W1 9 5 2 t^N4ls^Ycvv~
N0 0
0 01 9 8 5 t^_ QN蕄vX>eba g N*NSV,{ N*NSV/fQl[\eg W0WO(uCgv
Nnx['` =\{1 9 8 4 t^?e^Q[ QlbS g^0R1 5 t^ nfbeyrf0IlefW_TNg ( P r o s t e r m a n , H a n s t a d a n d L i , 1 9 9 6 ) (WNNv[0Wg-NSsN NN[0We[XTl g wck/{_y?eV{ (WYQg^ egSOvNhk N0RmQt^6eVQg^v@b g W0W eRM\WW W0WN^[^!jv9eS vQ~g/fb6RNQl[ W0WLY\W g9e0( OYcNT\W/eAmcLp|~ efYv g:g) N9e\Oc|N0[\eg W0WO(uCgv^lv
Nnx['`N:NNHN-NV=\{ gy~lyvzl QQg W0W^:WQNaev
N;m*N gV`0 sQeS N*NHhOxvz 0-NVQl l gCg)RasTWl goR
0
0~~eb 0 1 9 9 6 t^1 2 g1 5 e0 0
0 0yh ( J o h n s o n , 1 9 9 4 ) cQ [1 9 8 5 t^_QNXQ ?e^v NN?eV{XRNQl[ W0W[hQvb_ V MNONQlv]\ORRT[ W0WvbD0OY ?e^(W1 9 9 0 t^_ g[^ :NN[s:ghSv!j~Nm P0W0eT6erR7hvQN;mR \eSOS0QN uN\Pn,{N*NSV/fN1 9 9 4 t^w |6e-TAmQvV[We:_S WevAmSO6R bNN,Tv'Y!jP%Tjm9 (W1 9 9 3 t^_ g V[Q[|b6R'veP0|6e-MQ!k_eQ [2 7 yQNT[eN0 0[ 1 9 8 5 t^_QN uNsX>ebav,{ N*NV }/f1 9 7 9 t^N_vNt^[QNW@xe ( sSLpn] z) bDv'YQ\ OY 1 9 9 4 t^QNW@xe w[bD4ls^S/f1 9 7 9 t^4ls^v5 8 % 06q weg_f>fv/f(W^'YQQg:SW QNW@xeV[bDv NM4OWV[ _SNRDnRRvMNO0 Y(u W0W^:WTvsQT Tv:ONeg0sSO(W:ONV[bDv`Q N QNW@xe_N YvsQv W0WT TegSU\0FO(W6R^~_g N We0WCgv] zT T
NSL T7h (W:ON W0W8fv`Q N 0We?e^
N W0Wv"NzT .UzXR6eeQ 0We?e^_{(uaNGONv)Rm0_zT6e9XR Yv6eeQ NOc0We[XTvXl FOO0We[XTvP%TvQN:gO;NIN6R^S0 0
0 09hnc4T ( W u , 1 9 9 8 ) vch} y W0W@b gCgvSh6RN uN W0Wv gHeFUNSO(uT>yOlQckKNv$NQz0lwmwNvY0We[XTbQg^@b gv W0WRb$NRy~YVbyNONvFU(u0WT[^\OvS|0u0(W$N0u6R N Qg^v[XT_N[FUN(u0Wvc6RCgv^N-N+eSyё0\O:NNbc Qgl g(WyA W0WvON1\NvOHQCg0FOyёN1\N6eeQKNv]+R]'Y Vdkte*N z/f0We[XTNSOb g W0WvQlKbwPyv z0e6qywPSHN
NlQck YQlbVdkS u -N.Y?e^ybkN$N0u6Rv[ yyN;xN0Wev]NS mdNY[>yO g)RvFUN:gO0 0
0 0;`KN 1uqQN;NINv[l:_Rv6R^~_gN uNlQs^NHesKNv$N0(W:ON[?ey^v^:W[ST9ei NSU\wegvSh6R6R^SN?e^[XTvP%T:gO;NINL:N v^ bN[?elhvfYx0Y a n g , W a n g , a n d W i l l s ( 1 9 9 2 ) 0ONQQg W0WSl z^v^0ON W0W@b gCgy gSv\o(W6ev09hncNNvNGW w[6eeQ0FUNS z^ ( RRR]4ls^) Lu[TLONCgvHescpeKNsQ|v~Nm!jW (W1 9 8 7 t^Yg W0W1u8fAQv -NVQlvNGW w[6eeQ\XR3 0 % 0Q!kN(KQeTve =\{(WSh6R N -NVvQN g N*NvS_NNwvvSU\~He FOYgSh6R[hQvyN@b gCg@bSN 1\a1 9 4 9 t^MRv-NV7h -NVv~NmSU\~He\Of}Y S_MRvQN\Pn
NMR\
NOS u0 0
0 04 . 3 -NVvaNGON
0 0Sh6Rv,{N*NOP[/f-NVvaNGON ( T V E ) 0(KQeT ( S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 ) cQ T V E N g$Ny8^(ul $Ny(ulSNNmm ~-Nv[e(uT@b gCg{|W-Nvf[/g(u0[e~vaNGON+TIN]~Wevcy ib'YN01 9 8 4 t^_ aNGON~_NSbTkpT*NN@b g ( N*NNb[^ǖ(u
N7
Tǖ]) 0[e~(u@b~vaNGONpSa (W'`(
0aNGONt^t1 9 9 2 0 Ng ( L i , 1 9 9 9 ) U_N^ Nwz_^aNGONlS:NlQOclQS Sy gSv N*NOP[ ncNvD N1 9 8 0 t^N+gw N*N gvSy gS z]~b^v'YYpeaNGONlS:NNlQS (W1 9 9 0 t^N+g yNON(W*N^:WbN;N[r 6q P%0c:YTvQNV[:gO;NINsWs0 0
0 06q sQeaNGONv@b gCg~gv'YYpef[/gO(u N*NrINv[INSSbNck_{v ( (WbN weg ev
N w[v{v) :NaNG@b gTQg^@b gvON0yrINv[INN:NNHNTl\_ ( N a u g h t o n a n d W a l d e r , 1 9 9 5 l_ S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 ) baNGONc:N0We?e^@b g0d^SYc0R (W NbsQeaNGON@b gCg~gvRg bN\ZWcaNGON\O:NlQqQ@b gONv*NrIN[IN0aNGONQNNl gRe'` V:N7hv0We?e^bSO@b gvON1 9 N~+g(WYV[ Ye,gT-NVns g FO/f(WObONyNCg)Rv[?ey^ N Ype`Q N7hvONTSO@b gvON
NwQ gzNR aNGON[hQ(W?e^;uY\O g^8^lxv{~_g( QNN6e
N0Reg-N.YTw~?e^vV[{e4 SN0We?e^_0RvS_\v Npe40 0
0 0keu 0We?e^]~baNGON w\O0We{6eeQv N*Nv\o(Wegn ( O i , 1 9 9 2 ) 0 1 9 8 0 t^Ne g -N.Y?e^_z6eT T -N.Y?e^NTwFU[6eeQpev Ny"?eT T6R^ y"?eT T[cT~?e^~
Y6RvaNG N~ vQ~g 0We?e^O(u@b gSve_ SbYl_Lu~ve_ cRQQg]NSU\0 TeR"}[NNeEQ?e^{ ( Z w e i g , 1 9 9 1 ) 0 0
0 0 NN~Nmf[[baNGON w\O/fTN^:WoRNlQqQ@b gCgv N*NN^bRv6R^Re vS S NN~Nmf[[baNGON w\O/f_ wckyN@b gCgvS
N N*NJS*bP[9eieHh0 MR:_aNGON/f-NV
NS~NmagN Nvyr[Nir0_:_Yg-NVs(W
NcRaNGONv wcky gS [\b4NW%Nv6R^_gT ( S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 ) 0 0
0 0SO@b gQQg]NONv9hW/f(WASt^ei`Y[v S_e[e[Rf uv:_TV[RM6R^v)]n bQQglQ>yib'YNN^Q;mR01 9 7 9 t^lQ>y6R^ _Yte N>y ONeR:NaNGON0Qe[QQgNO1\NT0WeSU\vb_ [N[^zaNGONRv
Ne>e[0 N1 9 8 4 t^wybQbzTvcwaNGONvagN(WT0W]+R_'Y0aNGON g Ny;N{|W ,{ Ny{|Wy\OWS!j_ V:N[-N(WWSv N*NW^e!0]T8^]0_lw0WeS_@\[aNGON[ebrbrvc6R ( OY SNbDQ[ c6R]DS
N TaNGONKNvRRAmR) v^P6RRRvT%YONTyNONvpeegObaNGON0 0
0 0aNGONv,{Ny{|Wy\OYm_l!j_0Ym_lwv0We?e^ }6q/fYaNGONv N NaNGONTQg^WёLt^^Pc>k:NagN s^8^P6R[aNGONv uN0R~0NNNMQvr^0Ym_laNGON{|0 0,{ NyaNGONb__/f*OňbaNGONv wckyNON0y`Q N ONvte*ND,geg N*NNb N*N\VSO0:NNAQ{v:NaNGON ONT0WeS_@\N9 /f Ny N,0Wy\O4b~=^P[v
NRcpv*Oň0cv w[@b gCg?agv;NSV/ffNOvzs f[fvybQ z_ [ON!jT~%vf\P6R NS(W9eiv?el}TSSl N~b0R?elOb08^:N~=^P[yNONvpek]{vvyNONpeY0 NN1 9 9 3 t^gSs(WlSw N*NS g\1 0 0 0 [yNON [epeW[/f8 [ ( 0ONRGdObv 0
0-NVeb 01 9 9 5 t^3 g3 1 e) 0 0
0 0v0R1 9 9 0 t^N _l!j_:N/f gsOaNGONb__ V:N[vOagN O~v>yO;NINab_` gcя06q 1\a O~vV gON N7h WS!j_vaNGON_NG0RN"RV0~g/f1 9 9 2 t^,{Vc[^ e!0]T8^]V[yёbzN .Uve_b NN:NdW[@bVv\WV[@b gblQqQ@b gONv~%Cgly0RyN[N[Kb02 9 9 9 t^_l?e^[XT_NbWS!j_/f N*N1Y%0 0
0 0(WaNGONY7hS [Nv@b gCgTc6RCgNSoS'`(!j|v`Q N
N Tv\O:_aNGON
N TvW,gyr_ ~8^
Nb[N(WeT0WW
Nvg'Y]_0OY *P ( N e e , 1 9 9 6 ) baNGON w\O?e^TyNKNv
NckTDON ~8^4OWSO@b gvDNTON
Nckvy gS0 l\_ ( W a l d e r , 1 9 9 5 ) baNGON w\OlQqQ@b gCgv Nyb__ N'YWW^V g蕡l g]+R0m_ ( P e n g , 1 9 9 2 ) :_aNGONvJSy g'`( [Nv~%;N0 'k ( O i 1 9 9 5 ) zQ:_NV[:N-N_vpaNGON/f1uS0aNG0Qg^RB\{tv N*N]'YvYB\lQSv N*N uNUSMO01 9 9 0 t^N WDRv[ON{v:NaNGONvP6RvQ{ Y0WeQs wckvaNGONT~=^P[yNONqQX[vsa N(uv!j|f/f
NvQA~0 0
0 0(W9eieN aNGON6R^lNkv>y ONvYORTRR0[jkfNONv0WtR^ ;xN gHevW^S bDnNb/gHQv'YWV gONeRM0Rb/g=_v0WeON R N-NV_vSh;NINb/g=_vup;mvaNGONTb/gHQvPSvV gONqQX[0-NVvW^S z^NOeNGW6eeQvяvD,g;NIN~Nm ( UO 1 9 9 7 P 2 7 5 ) 0 0
0 0ySh6Rhf(Wb/gHesT0WtMOnHesv)R(uNX Hesv)R(uKNv$N0Vdk aNGONNNwvvX_N g[vNN0(W1uON6R^ N YaNGONSMOeW^v kW:Sv'YWV gONf gzNRv'YWy%ON@bNfv0Vdk N*Npeg w aNGON^8^vXs_N gSHesv Nb0?ehg( A l w y n Y o u n g , 1 9 9 9 ) cON1uaNGONTvsQv:SWRCgN ujkfv~nc0aNGONwQ g0We?e^vc6R NvON|~vhQ8^:w e6qR6R[0NTSN/f T N*N0We?e^ [N uN
NlQs^v8nbR 6R^SNV[:gO;NINTP% Vdk 8nbR
N3z[0
Nf0
NSO0aNGON[~NmSU\v bHe^l gS0R Y TeY-NVN[[[N-N.Y?e^[hQc6R NvT_V gON6R^vkvOR~NNg'YvsQl0aNGON gWkf~+R?e^@b gvV gONflxv{~_g09hnc4T ( W u , 1 9 9 8 ) Qrv[]\O aNGON R
Nbwv W0W@b gCg9eielT7bM|6R^ N uN N*N^8^GYyrv-NV_\^6R^ (Wy6R^ N 0We?e^[XTv0We W{Cg SlTgblCg [ W0Wvc6RCg NN(WZQ~~v[MO bzONvCg)R y{DёvCg)R NS[aNGONvc6RCg/f
NSRrRv 1\a-NN~'k2mv\^6R^0'Y^vOP[hfN\^6R^vyr_ ( UO, 1 9 9 7 ) 0'Y^ZQYfNy\OOe(W NN @gHh-N; cV[XTfgbLl^}TN0y/fQg0ZQYfNT*NQghQaNGONvcN0Nc6RW0WeluQR g[EvSlCg0YZSOb[_Nhf0We?e^[XT(uaNGON\O:Nc:Yv N*N]wQ NNOQglPcDbzaNGONv^bbyΘibDvhQΘi06q_egΘibDv6eeQ[XT@bc:Y ( UO 1 9 9 7 ) 0 0
0 0(W-NV_\^6R^ N NNcR:N g
N TCg)Rv
N TV 0WeZQ~~[XT/f NI{lQl NN ghQCg)RTyrCgNzrrr+RN:NNN_rSvQe_)Rv NI{lQl/f gS_0W7bSvQgl0NN(WaNGON~b0R}Y]\O v^ gCg_0R NRQg^y)RWё0 NI{lQl/fYegyl NN(WaNGONr^ gv]\O
N_0R Nky)R%m40{|yOT~Nm0WMO/f1uyYv?el0WMOT7bM|rQ@bQ[
N/f1uyYv6eeQT[?eCg)R@bQ[0-NV_vqQN;NIN\^6R^ T7bM|6R^TW^vV g?b0WN6R^ bvNORRRAmR'` N:NNHN0We?e^@b gTSO@b gON(W-NVQQgtQ [Nv^
NaD,g;NIN~Nm-NvD,g;NINON7hwQ gzNR (WD,g;NIN~Nm*NN gN1u Y1uNfRR0D,g0 W0WTvQN"N0\^6R^TNORRRAmR'`hf>y:SbXT gg8lOO(W T N0We (W T N0We'`v>y:S E\lvqQ T)Rv/fvS_3z[v0Vdk NNk(W1uv^:W6R^ Nf goR:NaNGONQR0 0
0 0yeW\^6R^
NNjkfN{tTONKNv9SM ONv0Wt^@\!j_TDnMn ;xNW^S _NN uNS b>yO
N3z[v>yO
NlQ0 0
0 0OgqVEhQ aNGON@b gCg~gg
Nck8^ (W'YYpe gQQg]Nv NNV[ YpS<\TlV \ONv@b gCg/fyNv ~8^(W N*N[^Q0vS aNGONv@b gCg\9hnc[e~@b/fSOv0 NNf[SO@b gCgS fNmSv-NVeS!j_06q yT\OeSGP](u(WS~nQQg\WyNON`S~[Ype te*N NN\WvNSyNONvL0Yg gsQe\ONvNUO-NVeSyrr weg/fyN0[^@b gvON
N/fSO@b gvON0vQNf[SO@b gCg/fQQgONy{D,gёv^)wvcwy Q\YXb NNtv Ny gHee_ ( Q i , 1 9 9 5 , W a l d e r , 1 9 9 5 ) 0NN(uNt1ubaNGON@b gCg~g:N^-NV=_v uN }^:W [^:W1Y%v N*N gOS^0 ( N a u g h t o n , 1 9 9 4 ) :N(Wlhve g L(WRt\7>k3uT0OΘiebagN_]0(W-NV 0We?e^@b gCgnboW N*NёNNvsQ.r00We?e^f}Y0W0O(WNNvc6R NRRONvΘi v^\O:NT*N+RvaNGON7>kvbO0 0
0 0 NN~Nmf[[ubaNGONvbR:NS[yN@b gCg/f\WONv)Y6q@b gCgb__v N, wlvnxRf v^Q[Hesv
N/f@b gCg /fNTT }^:WvzN ( N o l a n 1 9 9 3 ) 0 0
0 0(KQeT ( S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 ) [yaNGON@b gCgb__v[(u;NIN $\vQ/f[@b:_vV[(WёNN-NvOR c `u`^ (W1 9 6 0 1 9 9 5 t^ sSOS~nv-N\ONmSWte*NV gL|~vgk [NNhsQEQn;mRvX ^ck_ё:ggSQsNT[Nv ( S h e a a n d Y a n g , 1 9 9 4 ) 0S_1 9 7 9 t^ _Y~Nm1uSe ^:WR ( S_0WeS_@\[_e) [ё6R^RevRяeg_N(WYm_lw)n]^0R0R ( L i u , 1 9 9 2 ) bJT S_0WyN@b Dё9 5 % 1u0W NyNё~~ YSO0NN>e:P7bT^cO0
N~0WeyNL[~NmSU\v'Y!.s ?e^N6qu_ybkyNLNv[ sQNY0WeyNL0 ( L a r d y , 1 9 9 8 a , P P 5 3 - 5 7 ) 0 0
0 0 N*NS_vaNGON@b gCg~gv N,t^S_We$N*N;NQ,{ N v0R gя yN@b gCg(WY0We%NN(WN0We?e^vsQv@b geb ( kw) `QvS_vSOaNGON ^SOaNGON__gk
000We?e^hsQ[^SOaNGONgkvWSbS_LO70Sf'Yv uN:W0W ?e^[SeTnvRM ?e^OSRQb/gTRzT%ON0I{I{0 gnchf (Wz6eT)RmRMeb ^SOaNGONb4NW^R"}vf'YΘi 0We?e^__k[_SOaNGONfa0W[_^SOaNGON0 0
0 0{ KN NN-NVN[nxv^:W1Y%
N/f1uyN^:W~NmV gveHe( aY'`TlQqQ") @b bv N@bv^:W1Y%[E
N/f1uV[:_Rvab_`~_g@b bv0yr+R0W LV:NV[c:y cO~aNGONkyNONfYv7>k v^
N/fV:NaNGONQ(W0Wf gHe b/fV:N0WeL:N0We?e^/fk[N,gf}YvΘi0O0 0
0 0'Y[nfM TaaNGONkV gONb[Wf:_v^:WoR ( Sbflxv{~_g) 0(KQeT ( S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 ) cQ NyaNGON{|Wv$Ny _l{|WTYm_l{|W (W,g(
NvS_{|0 0Ygy^ck_y gSv g9hnc HNS g0We[XTvSOQZR
NX=:N*NNc:YDNvRRe aNGON~~ gHesMb gS0bN w0R(W1 9 8 0 t^Nv_lTq\ N SOQZRvsQ./f[N0W:SyNONv%Ngk (WN0W:S:ONυc:YegDNv~Nmzzv~g mdNUS*N[XTc:YNN@bvcwvaNGONvoR0l g[y gNCgv:_pl_gk c:YDN\fa0WS u 8^[0Rv^ck_y gSveHes\S_fRnfM0 Yg*Npcknxv Q['`vq_T/fy%vsQ!jTRRRAmRvekX\ g~JR1_0We[XTS[*NNc:YDNvSOQZRvW@x ( :Nc:YvDNcO[hQvυ0W) N _c[aNGONv~He0 0
0 01 9 9 2 t^ RN_ Sb{9eU1u1 9 8 9 9 1 t^v'})?eV{ bvQQg1YNrQ [yNNCgvgk NekQ1_ YaNGONXdcN[Nv~=^P[0S_-NVT^:W~NmveP evXYvy%ON
NQ_ g{v:N~=^P[bSO@b gONv_ V:N(Wy%TlQqQKNO`_Gv]+R]~)\V0FO g N*N SO蕰s(Wh:yl g[Nv.^R y%ON
NSSU\ \O:NNlQSv@b 0@b g
0 ZQ~~8^Bl 0yZZ
0vePbBlNlQSNV gONTv^ ( 0y%ON_ LRXdc~=^P[ 0
0-NVeb 0 1 9 9 4 t^1 0 g4 e) 0 0
0 04 . 4 -NVvV gON9eiTN0 0Sh6Rv,{ N*NOP[/f-NVvV gON9eiTNNvV gONbS6R]~Qs0 N*NV gONN[v;N{~{ N*NT T [kt^
NNV[v6eeQ ( z6e T)Rm) vpe V N,vO~NON g'YSvQ"RvYOvoR06q V gONN6qSo{~_g/eM Yg"R~g
NsO1\MQdN/eNT T[pev#N0{tT]NT NVYёTTy[ir%m4vb__V gDN vQ~g V[Ss"?e6eeQ`SG D P vk NM_k'Y_Y0 0
0 01 9 8 3 t^ V[ _YN6eeQzNfbS6R 6q y6eeQz6R^/fw}Tv V:N[
NN
Nb6R"?e6eeQ`SG D P kOv NM NV gONVN?e^1\z6eag>kNN v^[y[NO)Rmbb#Nv/f?e^[N
N/fNNv{t00R1 9 8 6 t^ V gONlTib'YvbS6R (Wy6R^ N Y{t^zSOONb gN0ON~Nm 01 9 9 5 t^,{7 g P 4 5 ) 0v^
NNN`_ V:N9hncNCg~Nmf[, Ygl gN[V gON giRYOCgv l gN goR~b0R}YvbSv^ gHe0WgbLT T 1 9 9 4 t^1 g bS6RQ!k6eeQzNf0hgT ( Y a n g a n d N g , 1 9 9 5 _NS a c h s a n d Y a n g , 2 0 0 1 , ,{8 z) :N ON[
gRvvc[Nb,g_elcS [ N*NONvyNiRYOBlCg/f[ON[
gRc[Nv9h,g0Vdk V gONvy gS/fbR9eiv9h,g -NVV gON9eiv~/f&T[ Np gVe~nc0(KQeT ( S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 , P P 1 9 2 8 ) ? V gONv uNs~HeN6q/f N*N^Nv0 NNxvz w0RNc S NNl g w0R06q (WNNNMR f0O0b ( L a r d y , 1 9 9 8 , P 2 0 6 ) _N(ueNfNVS
NQvX['vXyYq\TV gONevXRvOW^KNvvsQ0 0
0 0sSO gNvO(W-NVV gONv{t;N/f g'YS)Rm b/gReSgb g'YSV gON)RmvelKN N0[e-NVv NNV gON{t eN?e^[P d}YsQ|NXR uNHesvk _N(W"R
NfR_eg0v0R1 9 9 0 t^N 'Y-NWV gON_{NNOe^NT?e^N.U uN[0NN6e0Re4vbeQT\O:NeP Yge4vbeQTvpev y[6R^\~ONN uvyё Ng ( L i , 1 9 9 7 ) 0O N*N(W[ uNKN
N g^:W)RmvV gON (W1 9 8 6 1 9 8 8 t^6e0RvQ^:W)Rm2 . 7
Pvyё0[P;NINvNNk^:WzNf g)RSV0Ngvyё0O_N/f NP V:N[
NSbV gONNz6eOS-N6e0Rvyё0NfS_e _Y uHev5 5 % vl[zs V gONN[
N/eN3 3 % v6eeQzsv`N`ZPlvS_nfM0 0
0 0~Nmf[[N[V gONvg]"Rhsv^e_ N1 9 8 0 NV gONv>eCg)R9ei_ V gONvN_c3zekXR 1 9 9 0 9 1 t^S_V[V6eV NNyN~V gONvQV{Cge yrQ3z[ Neg 1 9 9 2 t^ :NNMQTv}T \s^SSR_~Nm9ei N_ RCgvRR(W0We[v&^4Y NR_N `
N0R0W~g/ffv~NmX4OWf'YvV gONN_c 1 9 9 2 t^S_t^NQX1 3 % 'Y~ g2 / 3 vV gON~%N_c NONN_c
NR_jeN0WSNSeb 0 1 9 9 6 t^6 g2 9 e) 0 NN~Nmf[[:_{tT]N[ON)RmvSO T/fV gON)RmnfM NMv gSV W-N.Y;uv~~T"RQV{Cg N>e~V gON ]N@\ gsQV gONDv;Negn/f1uV gON]cNvbJT (Wc~o{~_gvagN N V[vcwRvMNOasTWV gONv{tQNNl goRb6R]D Bl V:NNN\egcGS0Rf'YvV gONR0W1uNNN gQXR]Nvy)R@bQ[v0 gevbV gONv)RmAm1YR_eRCg9eiv/f1 9 8 6 t^-NV~NmSO6R9eixvzOv NNbJT NbJTcQNV gONQsvTy^Kbkeg^m9T^bDvR0sSOV gON~He9e S OR:_$R- tXT NSOSvV[:gO;NIN0VdkV gON~He9e[>yOy)R Sv^
N/f}YN0-NVvQ[f[e1\Np0NN:N?e^~FU/fNlN)R0sN[?eR_N%Nygb?eZQvcNN%)R'`;mR0Vvgb?e_{\vQ%)R'` uaN~rzvOXbL0 NN~Nmf[[XyV gONsQ_?e^v>yOy)R ev^V gON gft^{vXT] QNNl g{Qё/eNTvQNy)R%m4v b0Vdk S_yN蕄v!jv[NV g蕞XReV gON"RrQv`S SNt0b ( L a r d y , 1 9 9 8 , p p . 5 3 - 5 7 ) }N*NN[OncNQT1\N4ls^ Onc1\NkOTDёk V gON Nv(Wib _0=\{[vNQk NM "RrQv`S01uWevV gLSO6Rcbv7>k'YYpeeQNV gON0[V gONvvQNbeQ_Nc~XR0YN@b:y (WSvNASt^ =\{evXRvzNTc~v^:W1uS V gONv"RrQ]~v`S0V gON :P[DNvkO(W1 9 9 5 t^GSs^GW8 5 % _N/f g gRvnc09hncb ( L a r d y , 1 9 9 8 p . 1 1 9 ) vRg -NVvV*N;NV gL\O:N N*NteSOvQNGSvPsTV[SL'^CgRv~T]~cO~-N.Y?e^(uegfecv9hmVv~g'`vёDn0N}vI{N ( B a i , e t . a l , 1 9 9 9 ) vS *Nphf(W-NV b_8^PsvX[>k?S
T6R /f\o(WёqS:gv N*Negn
N/f-NVSU\v NycRR0?S
TX[>k6R Neb YObyN"N2bkV[c:Y S Neb[_NObNmTNKNvT|vP%0V:N6R^SvV[:gO;NIN Wy g蕄vSU\ -NV?e^v_zR Q1_0Vdk}vI{N ( B a i , e t a l , 1 9 9 9 ) bN)Rsvc6Rv~Tv?S
TX[>k6R S_\O?e^cTE\l_zv Ny gHee_0FOQ N!kN uNHesT[P%v[_ bv
NlQckKNv$NQz0UOnm ( 1 9 9 7 , P P 7 1 - 2 4 0 ) }N1u W0W^:WS0V gON9eiTNyOvk N*N=0bNcvY-NVN:N [y'Y!jvP% bv>yO
NlQv
Nn S b?elRqN0FOSh6R*N%Nv\o(W_gv^l g_0R-NVNYv~Nmf[[Nv^ gla0N1 9 9 5 t^w bJT>f:y-N\WV gONvhQbQ.U]~(WhQ-NVS u g:NNwvOP[/fq\ NwW^01 9 9 2 t^W _Yy gSV gON S_e[vV gON g2 / 3 N_cbRR6e/es^a0(WW]
NY9 0 % vS^\V gON]~y gS0V gONlS0RNT\OlQSvR S fN[B\v wlhy^:W
NlQ _v8RQ.UNSNYVlQSTDv@\y gS/fbS6Rv N*N9e06q (W:ONck_y gSv`Q N V gONvlQSS b'Y!jP%0 0
0 0UOnm[-NV$Ny{|WvSy gSv}fNSh6RTP%KNvsQ|0UO ( 1 9 9 7 , p p . 1 0 1 - 1 3 8 ) }N1 9 8 7 9 3 t^(W-NV V gONNSv@\y gS0(WR6R[0NTSN/f T N?e^NtNv8nbR N ySvy gSN u'Y!jvP%0yYRgN(Wy?e^Q萺Nc6R z-NvV{|P%0P%v,{ Nye_/fvcbV gTlQSvNRM~N gbzT{tNlQSvybQCgv?e^[XTT gCgRM W0W0L7>kTvQNDnv?e^[XT0 ( UO, p . 5 5 ) 0(W,{Nye_ N (W/nbwmY^zyNlQS\O:NV[TlQSvT\ObP[lQS 6q_$N*NON
Nck8^vTyNf ( OYNONVSQNpN) V gDNN_ly0RMR ( H e , P 6 0 , P 6 9 ) (W,{ Nye_ N (W7hvTlQS yN N6epN?e^NhTy@b gCgv~;ueP0Wb?e^vNly~MR0 ( UO, p p . 5 7 - 6 0 ) 0(W,{Vye_ N V gONTYVlQSvTDON-Nv?e^NhEeaNO0OV gDNvN0 0UOTvQN-NVf[ZWcV gONNSv@\y gS/f N*N1Y%0'YYpeNSvV glQSv~Hel g9e u(W1 9 9 4 t^-NVv
0lQSl 0N_ -NVv
0lQSl 0v T TCgSR(WNNSvV glQSl g/{_0?e^c gvN gfYvbhyCg Q萺NNfTP%^8^nfM (WUO ( 1 9 9 7 ) v}-N yV[c6RlQSvSy gSvY[O mS0RD,gY09hnc ( l_S a c h s , W o o , a n d Y a n g , 2 0 0 0 ) , -NVvVE6e/es^ahv' TWo' y Nv]'YpeMO S fN'Y!jvD,gY0*NpeW[1 9 9 4 01 9 9 5 01 9 9 6 01 9 9 7 t^R+R/f9 8 N01 7 8 N01 5 6 NT1 6 9 NCQ0 0
0 0UO ( 1 9 9 7 , p p . 7 1 - 1 0 0 ) _N}N(W W0WvV[@b gCgT W0WO(uCgNfvSh6R N W0WO(uCgSy gSvYOP[ (WyY weg /f N*N'Y!jP%v z (W*N z gS_pNVS W0WybQCgv?e^[XT:NN QVSNNvybQch0(ue-pN W0Wv'YRegV gL0Vdk (W1 9 8 8 9 4 t^'Y!jv-NVW0WR-N Y g7>k[ybCgvV gL[XTTNNv;N{NwSeQP%0Q N!k Sh6R NebR N W0WO(uCg^:W S Neb6R^SNP%TV[:gO;NIN0 0
0 0(W1 9 9 5 t^ 0VEf^
0Lv4 1 *NV[P%%N z^c^ -NV cP% z^c
T,{N( S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 ) 0~~P%TV gDNvn(u\ NekMNOlQO[sX[?el6R^v/ec0Sh6Rv bHeg_N'Y'YNpNvQe_)Rv XR9ei/ecvckbHeg0ylQS!j_SbNQ萺NzSV gDNv N*N]wQ0 0
0 0SY Sh6RN uNNeHesv~Tv^8^
Ns^I{v6eeQRM01u7bM|6R6R^Sv[QQgE\lvgk bNWaNKNSHesv
Ns^I{6eeQRM0~NRlwm0W:S8fyrCg6R^SN[QF0W:Svgk [ bNlwmTQF0W:SKNSHesv
Ns^I{6eeQRM01u{ (KQeTl~ ( J i a n , S a c h s a n d W a r n e r , 1 9 9 6 ) @b}vlwmTQFw:SX'Yv6eeQ]NS N*NevXRvW<\|pe
NNP6RN^:WvV ;xNRRR]vo NN uN[?eCgnfMv:_p
Nn ]~ bYbv^S['Y!jSb0-NVvW<\|peN1 9 7 8 t^v0 . 2
NGS0R1 9 9 4 t^v0 . 4 3 3 ( UO, 1 9 9 7 , P 2 5 ) yY:N[e1 9 9 4 t^vW<\|peV:N[Nwv
Nl6eeQ NO0ON
Ns^I{0yYc_ N*NW<\|pe^[ev0O 1 9 9 5 t^:N0 . 5 9 0-NVvSh6Rv^l gcONLuvQN0We6R^
NfcOvY\eD0 0
0 0[p`}YQ!kNbRv~NmSU\
NN ^:W [?ey^TllegOc*NNCg)Rv^cO[?e^CgRv gHe6Ra0S_vS_QR L:NNSSb4xgb?eZQv?elWe/f[?ey^b_bv9h,g02 0 0 0 t^ -NV[N _Y0RW,g6R^v9ei/fQ6R^S*alvsQ.0W T O veQO$R_NO-NVv6R^
NQ[hQ1ugb?eZQWe /f1u-NV?e^NTV?e^s^I{NN zQ[0-NVv~Nmzl(WkQASt^NT]NASt^N gU\ ll Rl lQSl N)R6R^I{ebnb`
Y0RlV NASt^Nv4ls^0yr+R/f gяck(W6R[virCgl [~NmSU\ g'YaIN0hg\Q s^V Z\X( 1 9 9 2 ) [RgNNl_?eV{SS[NfHesTNGW6eeQvckbq_T0-NVSRW T O v$R zO-NV?e^ wQ[n!j|b~SRv8nbR\OQSOb0W T O RBl^gk Slrz ,{ NN 8nbRf 3z[ lQs^ SO0W T O bXTVBl-NV6R[[sNRvwQSOe zh OY^bkZQv~4YeNl_v0WMOvwQSOe g ^bk
NQyN~%vLNhvwQSOe g0FO/f-NVvzl zNASR\ TFUb*Yz *YIs l gEQR V N uRzl zv`l _Nl g[lSl( S_ z_SJTl_ Y SOl_$R[) OSlgbl_
N0R>yOv^l TT/ec0 0
hQfN[
