yO3z[ZvQ NyI{~6Rv>yO~g [ cgqNv~+RegRMy
yOv)Rv:NNN_rSNNv)Rv0ytasTW w:/f:NN~I{~6Rv>yOy^cOckS_t1u Eea bv ( _N(W[XTNv\oa) 0 S[OT旯e<\v>yO;NIN NvnfMw:t fw:/f?e^[XTbSWeyёv Nyel [(uegcvWe)Rm V Q\lQO[Weyёv
Nn /fkvcvWeN
N0(KQe ( S a c h s , 1 9 9 6 ) (KQe, , Thg ( S a c h s , W o o , Y a n g , 2 0 0 1 ) ~*NcON N*NT{Hh0bNs(Wi*NT{Hh0Y(KQeThg ( S a c h s a n d Y a n g , 2 0 0 1 ) ve[!jW@b:y ~NmSU\/fRRR]ov N*N z0yr+R0W Thg ( N g a n d Y a n g , 1 9 9 7 , S a c h s a n d Y a n g , ,{1 5 z) cQ (W N*N gPt'`vNLu RRR]vo 1u>yOTyRRR]!j_@b_v~~D NS*NNsQe!j_vR`QV{KNvNN\O(u@bQ[01ueX[(W>yO&^egvD6evNb,gKNv$NQz RRR]v}YYTNf9(uvXRKNv$NQz @bNS_TNfvHese vRRR]v!j_1\Y ^:W_v~~D_NY0e6q>yOSek_ gsQRRR]v gHe!j_vD S_NN:ON~~De (W
YBgvRRR]!j_KNMRHQN{USvRRR]!j_ hf~NmSU\/f*NNRRR]v{US!j_0Rev
YBgv!j_veko z06q YThg ( N g a n d Y a n g , 1 9 9 7 _N S a c h s a n d Y a n g , 2 0 0 0 , ,{1 5 z) @b:y YgSV[ekv>yO]~SsNRRR]v gHe!j_ ~NmSU\v_eg YRRR]v-N6k vc!jNRRR]v gHe!j_0(WSV[ D,g;NIN6R^ gRe1u^:WgvQ0N[vRRR]!j_0SD,g;NINV[R vMQ9~~D:N_egv'Yc]NSR N:gO 'Yc]NS gS1uv^l gD,g;NIN6R^W@xevT_>yO;NINSO6Reg[s D,g;NIN6R^W@xe/fSs gHev]NS!j_v9h,g0(W:OND,g;NINW@x6R^e !jN1uD,g;NIN6R^R v]N!j_eg'Yc]NSyS'` /f1 9 3 0 t^NT1 9 5 0 t^NT_>yO;NINV[v[bR0W]NSvtW@x 1ue_euNyS'` T6KQTQs|^Xe
N0R2 0 N~-N gT_~NmSO6Rvx^X[0 OdTNNwvvX~He0 0
0 0:NVT{,{ N*N bN{0WRR-NV(W1 9 5 9 t^N^zwegv_>yO;NINSO6Rvyr_Y N
0 0( 1 ) OcQNT[]NTvv[NONv^c6R@b gON ySO6R)R(uhQONvV[@b gCgT-N.Y;ueg_V g]N蕄v)Rm0V gONv)Rm(ueg!jNPs0bDsT]LNk{]LNfvXs0y]NSU\!j_1uD,g;NIN]NS z@bR 0OncSThg ( S h i a n d Y a n g , 1 9 9 5 _NS a c h s a n d Y a n g , 2 0 0 2 ,{1 2 z) ve[!jW ]NvXsXR uNvV uNagT uNDeLNv6eeQkeg[s /fRRR]ov N*Neb0 0
0 0( 2 ) ONvV[@b gCgT-N.Y;uSO6R(ueg~~~T'`v]NbDR NR(W[Yy]NTv^:W
NX[(We TeRzNY^8^NNSv]NON y~T'`vV[bDR_SNRRR]Q!jv'Y O^NNSv]NLNy{|S u0y~T'`vV[bD;u(W1 9 3 0 t^NvT /fǖ(uYegSD,g;NINV[vN[6Rv ( Z a l e s k i , 1 9 8 0 ) (W1 9 5 0 t^Nv-NV /f(WegTT N'kvN[vcR N[bv0y~T'`vV[bDRASR gHe0W)R(uNsQeRRR]v gHe!j_TRRR]vNNQHegvMQ9~~D0vQyrO1\/f1 9 5 0 t^N-NVv6 9 4 *N'YW] zyvTTc^v1 5 6 *NsQ.] zyvvR *NR(W_weQ (WY^NNSvONbR0WR^N N*N^'YvRRR]Q S_el gN^NNSv uNDev^:W ( ?b 1 9 8 4 ) 0OY \O:N1 5 6 *NsQ.] zyvKN N (W N_vcR N N*NNN uN(ue:g^]NvN ёRwvON(W]^b S_e[:g^v Bl
NN/ed N*N uNN ёRwv'YWNNON07hv?e^bDRN'Yc]NStvS_ N0(WT ;uS_@\[D,g;NIN]N!j_T'Yc]NS!jNve.s}NNbReW ( Z a l e s k i , 1 9 8 0 ) ~b0R0R[ ( L e n i n , 1 9 3 9 ) RRQN[D,g;NIN]NSyr_vt _egT;uS_@\!jNN[0-NVv'Yc]NSv}N?b ( 1 9 8 4 ) ~b0R0 0
0 0( 3 ) -N.Y;uS_@\vS_|~0W!jN]NhQS 'Yyb uN uN~ D,g;NINlQS~tN0S^TOKNv6Ra:g6R lRyf[{t( (W-NVy:N[{t) 0NSD,g;NINONSU\QegvvQN~~!j_T{tel0 T N"NvYnT6evCg(WT]N0"?e0V[L0Y0irN@\0irD@\TvQN:ggKNvRrR ?e^^zwN:ggKNv6Ra:g6R0-N.Y;uS_@\y6Ra:g6R[te*N~Nm^zw N*NvS_ gHevc6R:g6R0 gB\?e^TZQv[XTqQ T[;uSO6RlviRYO g"}SCg0VdkNN goR\O*NSO6Reg g'YSiRYO0R[:N T-N.Y;u^S_bte*N~Nm~~b N*N'YlQS0FO(Wy6R^vvB\ l g gHev6Ra0?e^TZQ~~(WbzlQST(W@b gLN gWeCg N1 6 8 8 t^(WVRzvwQ g1u~>y ( SbyNONvR{v6R) TrzSl|~v[?ey^b_bf[gq y[?eSO6R(W?el SvvB\^zN6Ra01ue:ONyvB\vCgR6Ra T_>yO;NINSO6R:N6R^SvV[:gO;NINR N_'Yzz0 0
0 0( 4 ) -N.Y;uS_@\(W:ON-N }^:Wv`Q N O(u NWYirDs^ahT N*Nv z_egOFUTvO s^a0*NSO6RvS_}YvcяRf`+Y ( L e o n t i e f ) vbeQNQl@b_Qv~g0[e-NV5 0 t^NirDs^a zv\O NLuL( W o r l d B a n k , 1 9 8 4 ) cON~vU_06q Rf`+YbeQNQl
NQ
N TbeQKNvfN [
Nnx[[m9Tv g~ Bl _N
NcOOSN>f:yvQyNDv gHeoR:g6R0WpQ ( R o l a n d , 2 0 0 0 , ,{ Nz) ~N NN~Nm!jW N!jWf -N.Y;uvR` z_0RvGWa/feHesv0 0
0 0( 5 ) 6q !jND,g;NINbRv]NS!j_TD,g;NINONQ!j_ /f4xOWN u]NST~~vbR!j_vD,g;NIN6R^W@xeeg[sv0/f,{ N!k-N.YCgSv~Nm6R^v>yO0-N.YCgv>yOvHQQagN/f(W6R^[cv^zWeCg /ffRi}T0fROryNNCgT:NpeOYvnmR-Nv~rP``eg[sv0(W6R^[cv:ONlQs^zNasTW bv6R^[c
NS gHe0T_>yO;NIN~NmSO6R/f1u N*N?e^ gav,{ NySO6R
N/fNSvoTSNlQs^zNNNCgv?aNfvNN\O(u-NQsv0T6KQ( H a y e k , 1 9 4 4 , 1 9 6 0 , 1 9 8 8 ) :N gHev6R^[cS\O:N7hlQs^zNT?aNfv~g Qs0(KQe ( S a c h s , 1 9 9 6 ) :N !jNSD,g;NIN~Nmv]NS!j_vV{eu (W:OND,g;NINW,g6R^e YN uw gNNwvvX~He06q S_!jNv\oR]~=\ bRRR]vQS_ev
YBgveP yV{euv gNN\[vw gHev V:NySO6Rl gb6R^ReRSvsQv6R^W@xe0f N,v S_~NmSU\v_egVv
NSV[e [8^u_WTv6R^SU\] zf[0[HQV!jN]NS!j_c Neg/f~Nm6R^ YyNONv~~~gQ Neg/fl_SO6R YlQSl6q_/f?elSO6R YN6Rl;N[_N g~~ NN[?eR YCgRv6RaSegSV[vab_`TL:N0 ` ( N o r t h , 1 9 9 4 ) `T)n
N
N TNT_>yO;NIN~NmSO6R0-NVTTqQNZQKNvzN(WVE?el S
NR N Ny6R^B\!k
Nv6Ra0Vdk kl N[-NzNOe av?elv [NN(WvQ1 9 5 6 t^ 0AS'YsQ|
0v-NcQL?eRCg( k 1 9 7 7 a ) 0 N?elzN/f-NVTOWe6R^oS]+Rv'Yof0 0
0 0NASt^NW^-NS uN$N*Nv~Nm6R^SS N*N[~NmSU\ g bq_T S N*N gckbq_T0?eRbe1 9 5 4 t^5 g6 e^bkNn+gl RSU\wegvN)R6R^ (uSSf[[:Nl gzNRvb4xNTT_v uNvSf b/g9eSTtS^vVYRfLagO ( ?b~-N, p 1 1 7 ) 01 9 5 5 t^6 g?e^LXTvI{~h%Nv[irM~6R9e:NNAS]N~]D6R( ?b~-N, p 1 4 5 ) dkSS[~NmSU\ gO\O(u0 0
0 0NASt^NcLve6R^NV[:gO;NIN6R^S V[[~NmvhQbWeTc6R SOr"N:Nyr_0ye6R^(W1 8 N~v'k2mef/fgl gzNRv6R^ @bNASkQN~cL{|
0 0N)Y-NVQYvf[ Ta 1 9 5 8 - 1 9 6 1 (W-NVS uv'Y!jeR/fN{|SS
N{kN gYv N*NN:N`gR
NFON{|SS}veRN*g gYdk`p N{| g}vbN-Nv{kNNpe_N*g!k'YeR-Nv{kNNpe N/f(W_}Yt^bS uv1ugb?eN:N bv`gR0 gf[cQ Eea d4xOW
NS bYdk``v~@\0-NVQYvf[N)Y Ta !kSe Nt^v'YeR{k\ NCSNN0-NV[eShvCgZvZQSNW:N 01 9 5 9 t^1 9 6 1 t^v^ck8^{kNTQ\Q uNSpe (WVCSNN]S
0 ( N0fbSU\v\g 0 ,{NwS p . 2 7 2 ) -NVf[ё ( 1 9 9 3 ) NV[~@\ShvpeW[:NOnc{v~g/f 0NN-NVQQgv^ck8^{kNNpe 1\SVCSVASN
00wmYf[Nb( 1 9 9 6 , p . 7 ) N[eDe:NW@xv8h{_N_Q\ NCSN~vNN{kv~0wmYf['YY Ta Nt^eR{kNpe:N NCSNv0O \ uvNpe'Y~(W NCS N~vN ( C h a n g a n d W e n , 1 9 9 8 , P e n g , 1 9 8 7 , p p . 6 3 9 - 7 0 , K a n e , 1 9 8 8 ) 0 0
0 0 Nt^'YeR/fCgN6R6R^S bvNxy%N z^v N*N g}YHhO01ueGS S SS SS>PRI{ N|R[S[>mv?el[R -NVqQNZQv?eCgb:N N*N[hQ
NS6R~vePCgR0[SS>mRv=\}Nb ( 1 9 9 3 ) [SS>PRv}Nb ( 1 9 9 6 p p . 3 7 - 8 6 ) [ NS NS GS Sve.s}T e i w e s , ( 1 9 6 2 , p p 8 5 - 8 8 ) 0NR_ ?e^[N,T
N0R>yO
N[NNvybX S,T_0RLkR_vX ZQv[ N~\OQvnm8YTZb ON:N w v^NNR [ybS[aL?el[ g_?e^_0RvD[hQ1Y w [XTN(WZGPv`bTNv:k-N^e V ZPQgzvQV{ bNLuS
N{kN gYv'YeR0 c _#kTe/-N ( C h a n g a n d W e n , 1 9 9 8 ) NSNbve.s} eRHQ1u'YpY0 1 9 5 8 t^kl NSR'YR (W uNRS g5 9 9 N(TvagN N Bl uN1 1 9 9 N(T0 1ueS9h,g
NS0R*NN N _YSShQlp Vdk(W'Y}Yt^bbQlXRR_SZP Wp \QlvpwQpb^ (W*N z-N'Yg(gkc0R
Nkl NN6R[Q\Oel ( QNkQW[[l) :_Ql d^[
i O_Y^
Nq_T0R NCSNN vQ-N N~vQASN/fpyb$R[:NS>P:gO;NINRP[vr^ZQXT gfYR:NoQS>m 0W[SOWRP[ ( Nb p . 2 2 0 - 2 2 1 ) 0(Wy?elSR N T~r^:_ N~bN
Nb
NceO ( Nb p . 2 2 2 ) 0OYlS _SS 1 9 5 8 t^|Nя4
P0WZ8YTib'Y OV[_-NRb
PXR [ENN_-peQNNvS_ @bNYu~QlvS g WF(
0-NqQZQSDe 0, ,{9 9 , p p 7 4 - 7 6 ) 0Y5][N7 0 Ne| wY
NbvtS/f1 5 0 Ne [_Q3S1 9 5 9 t^|N/f1 . 5 4 Ne SY[^/f4 . 0 5 Ne0^
NQgSY\[EN1 . 4 4 Ne8Y'Y:N2 . 5 7 Ne ( Nb p . 2 2 2 ) 09hncNZbvN kl N:N|Y_T
N[ S NNQ\ 1 9 5 9 t^%fdby9 CSNN ( Nb p . 2 2 2 ) 0 Te(W9 g
NwmO -NqQQ[XRN~vNe_- ( Nb p . 2 2 3 ) 01uelQqQXTm
N hQt^vS|(WN N*NgQT[ R
NQ6e _-XR 1 9 5 9 t^%fYeR1\ _Y^ _eg( C h a n g a n d W e n , 1 9 9 8 ) 0 0 0
0 0(WeR]hbSv`Q N T~?e^(W
NbvSRtS:N/f6~LeNccqN NbwN yR (Wkl NBlQl|JSt^|vc:y N_ 1 9 5 9 t^yTwtQwSwNyRR FcSbWB
^ 'Y!jTQl d.R|0uS u<|e(urR35g Sb{kN Q{kNTyRZ ( Nb p . 2 2 5 ) OeRf ^ ( Nb p p . 2 2 3 - 2 2 8 ) 0f g@b 0?el'Y
0 qNbNUcN bS['YvNNa$RR ( Nb p p . 1 4 5 - 1 4 7 ) 0SS[[kSSYbkvcb}Y_ROWN
NN N`0FOncNgeh Cg^dgb{v
0pT^y[Wvkl N 0 ( p p 02 2 5 - 2 5 7 u) } bSq\O~_g_Mb N*Ng T0W{kNv~[5ub]~0R-NWSwm-NqQ?el@\8^YNvRlQ[0[_QSSkmlQ>yZQYfNS
T 0wBlf
0~kl NQO 0ncbwSv N*NlQ>yV*N^P[vNS{kN`Q/fg:N`Nv N*N{kN`S5 % N*N1 1 % :_ N*N1 5 % N*N`S2 0 % Y gvQgP[QNNeNN OO(WbN4NMosQ
N b6ewegv'YN"N_v?Qz~ NV~vN {kN N~v
T]S0
0 (
ON
0qQTV'YNN~[ 0 ,{9 wS p p . 6 4 - 6 5 ) 0R\GYT
N\[NwSNTNNN _NbJTNkl N0Nb~ SSRtQO4l)Rno Bl1 9 5 8 t^v!j0^Q{y4l)R] z z-NQl[hQ'N1YN1u PtY N7hRR r^Sb{kNvNN^8^nfM0WB
^'YPS_N/fS u(W*Ne g WB
^)R(uePvCgRxYalYsY :kS~vY *jLaN 'Y dyrCg ( Nb p 1 9 5 , p 2 4 2 , p p 1 5 1 - 1 5 2 ) 0OSbNvsa Nv^~0R1 9 6 1 t^ _NN 0?el'Y
0 Sm_^ j[6R^ gsQ ( Nb p p 1 5 2 - 1 5 4 ) 0ySl6R^vP _egkl N;`~:N 06~eN Nb1\up
00 QQgWB
^'Y-Nr NvjLb:Ne gVnRntvp09hncNSve.sU_ ( 2 0 0 0 p p . 5 6 - 6 2 ) , 01 9 5 9 t^{kNv`Q1\Glb0RSN 1 9 6 0 t^3 gkl N[:|\Oc:y 1 9 5 9 t^1 2 g- 1 9 6 0 t^2 gu-n G T?e NSQs'Y{kNvsa -NqQ-N.YybluwYQ-nvay WB\~~m NybS OWRP[ r^
O
N~ -N.YbN[Yl:SYt-N/u'Y{kNva :NSV/fl;Ni}T
N{_^ ^ZQ9hP[
Nck ZQ~~%N
N~01 9 5 9 t^T0W{kNv`Qb0R-N.Y [1 9 6 0 t^%f -N.Y|蕌T_lwYR+R>m]\O~S_l[^Sg nxN:|_w'YybN{kNvN[ 1 9 6 0 t^2 gOw~[r^Sv`Q{-NSb`
YN gsQQQgNS 0vvYAm
0 0nm^
0vQb09hnc NNZQQ~[ch 1 9 6 0 - 1 9 6 1 [_Q3S3 3 NNS{k 6 N ( я1 / 3 ) S u 6 3 w g}vNTNNN0 Nch_eg1u0Q3QQg>yO~NmSU\bJT 0 NeSh 1u/n
0 _>e 0Bg_e1 9 9 4 t^3 gS ( p p . 4 5 - 5 1 )
RQ01 9 6 0 t^4 g_kl N[[eZSOvrp[ Oeu g
N[ 6 gN _Y[0Rb/f wck?aab[QQgv%N Nv g RS^/f\v#Nc~WB
^萄v[P;NIN :_}TNTlqN~ ( NS p 5 8 ) 0 0
0 01 9 6 1 t^ Rkl N\OQ$Re Neb d6~eN Neb[Ql\OQr^ek FO{kNsa~~^0kl N/ec~r^ NSg :Nyr'YV/f[0W[SOWSXd=^YN W9e
N{_^ Vdk l;Ni}Te0ehTi`eg_N/ec N$Re ( NS p . 6 2 ) 01 9 6 1 t^qS:g]vp nc
N[hQDe 1 9 6 1 t^6 gMR y^\0W:SuN]1 3 . 5 N 1 9 6 1 t^4 - 5 gwP!n0RS gv-NVN]4 5 0 0 N 01 9 6 1 t^Y q\ NwvJW _] `l NN:S 6 gN{kN 1 6 7 0 0 N 9 gN
NGS0R 3 5 6 0 0 N 0R1 0 g NJW N0WYAmmNpe 1 0 N VS?QVSsY 9 8 5 N g+Y9eZ 8 6 9 N *N+RWB\~~][hQ+vu ( NS p . 6 0 ) 0 0
0 0R\GY hTi`egI{N NaNgv~Nkl N
N N7h NNgR;N _R te?eV{01 9 6 1 t^5 g7 ekl NyblhTi`egyblQqQXv5ubJTU_ N,gN
Nh` FO(WR\GY:_pBlceX_ k(W6
7 gv-N.Y]\OO
NXy 0/f&TSRX [hQ1u>yXTQ[
00dk_XQNN N YKNhQce ( NS p . 6 2 , ?b~-N, p . 9 9 2 ) 0QlYu0Wnb`
Y ^8f_N _>e0_Yw:SQQgXVe| (W-N.YeN NKNMRsSLSO uS dwN'YS~N01 9 6 1 t^1 0 g5]*N Nt^MR'YRXv~ew 1\ g NRKNNvS[LNSN0R7b0kl N gHQUcIc0R~Nm
Yva NS/cKYweg 1 9 6 1 t^9 g k(W^q\-N.Y]\OO
N[^V]0R7^ b_R N)Y)YT
NGS ( NS p . 6 0 ) 0 0
0 0s(W] g Ync kl N_e1\['Y!jeR{kN Nvv`r[hQw` FONb` S,gRS (ub6~eN ?el[ OrNCgvRlS6RS['Yva v^CSe~v[~bev?elz4xS eN_?el;NR _N/f_eg>yYeRTei-NNNR\GYI{NS uQzv9h,gSV0 0
0 0!kNLu g'YveRv^
NIQ/fkl N*NNvjL N/fN6Rrv>yO;NIN6R^\V[:gO;NIN6R^Sv_6q_g0Vdk \~Nmf[VY_;N h( S e n , 1 9 7 7 , 1 9 8 1 ) cQNLu
N gv'YeRv^
N/fUS~:|_w /fyrCg6~(W|w:e\ gPv|-N(ueNNv u;m
N~ g:|v NB\Nlv%` 0 gThg ( L i n a n d Y a n g , 1 9 9 8 ) (u-NV'YeR-NvncfN NGP`0'YeRhbSN_ T0Wr^萁ybkQlYQR (u%NSbRSbQS_eQQg-NnfMvwPv^
0 0yN6R6R^(W-NV'YeR_fvv`g/fS[qS:g [?elRqN01ue-NV'YeRfkl Nv?eV{~{_^1Y% -NqQZQQ NP (W1 9 6 2 t^NCSN'YO( -NqQ-N.Y]\OO)
N&T[kl Nv?eV{ kl N\Oh ( ?b~-N, p 3 2 3 ) 0(Wl;N6R^ N y[qS:gO1u'Y1Y%v;N #N NS Q0FO/f(W[rNujLe Nll;NN?e6R^l glQv?el8nbRegQ N[qS:g rNjvkl NN6q'YCg(Wc0 ZQvB\'YRN(W1 9 6 1 t^ NWB\g_
NQ/eckv?eV{0 kv[CgZNNr NvjL
Nv[ VdkN1\_6q(uNvCgReg6R ?elRqN e_QV{CgT[CgZ0 (W1 9 4 9 t^mmpNS[ZQVlZQ 1 9 5 7 t^GSNl;NTvI{S[ZQ S1 9 5 9 t^GSNZQQS[>m_ ZQQ0R'Yv~r^tSQl g6R^:g6Reg6Rakl NvCgR0 0 0
0 01 9 6 1 - 1 9 6 2 t^(WR\GY \s^I{ _f>m[ N -NVv~Nm?eV{hQbb`
Y0R'YMRvrQ0\s^mwVQv%N'` NhQR/ecR\GY 1 9 6 1 t^ybr^N[te ]V EQ[ cve/{_
NR ;N _ Y0}6qh`/eck d6~eNv?elR TeScQ^(WQL0R\GY hTi`eg \s^ HN:N-N.Y?eV{v[~vYepezrrr a0R_mv'au 1 9 6 2 t^YR\GYr_Tk Bl>e[?eV{ Ru[kv 0Nv `Ob/f
NSfNv0
0 ( 0Rn UO[ hmR\GYNVnR 0
0WSehT+g 0 1 9 9 5 t^1 1 g2 0 e) 0ncRV_ 1 9 6 2 t^%f R(WNNme_N0R 0SS
N{kNvN/fQ0RSfN
NSv
0 vQe R`
Ny$a$a0W 0bS_;N-^e QNyN
0( R 1 9 9 8 , p p . 1 0 3 , 1 0 5 ) 0R\GYS_e*g0R QyN/fGS S SS SS>PR mmp@b gS[>mv_6q~g01 9 5 9 - 6 1 t^v'YeR[ NN~r^萄v:Rogm 0 N`weg1\b_` Y
NgS
0 V:N 0~p:SNlvQ` NQvzrrr zkbNt^NY
0 NNnZi 0[hQ/fevzrrrJU
0 ( NS p 6 4 ) 0 yNlSbv:gOl gv``XQtSHNy:N 0-NVNl[(W}Y {kN_N
N`weg S
0( NS p 6 4 ) 01ue~r^NlO HNS
NwS>yO[` FO_NS/f gawN[0S[/f1 9 6 0 - 1 9 6 3 t^-NVS uNYY[rkv0W N?eZQ;mR vQ-N;N g-NVl;NZQ -NVRRZQ SqQQeVQ N/S0NNS[qQNZQv;N?elBl1\/fvz Nt^'YeR-NqQNZQvSN{|j0N0W N?eZQ;mR_eg(W1 9 6 9 t^vnt6~
O 1 9 7 0 t^v NSb NSR-Nmmp ( hgfIQ 1 9 9 4 t^) 0 0
0 01 9 6 1 t^kl N _YnxRwS]N'Yxy NS_elfnxS[SN0R7b /fI{0R_egMbS;eP{0N1 9 6 1 t^
NQwQSOR\GYI{Nv~OP;mR k_N/f(W*Ne g\PbkT FONQ_mY k
N:N] gUO0NS_e:NhQZQ[ NP[
NqN QqN {kNN N_N;eQ Nb~eY ( NS p 6 4 ) 0(WySR N ;N _b['YeRs[vkvyfN0u[@g0kl N0W:N'Yv1Y%/f1ueQNT|
N Y cQN 0N:N~
09e:N 0QN:NW@x N|:N~
0 SV0RN-NVSN1Y%vQbFUKNNN?eV{0 NQV{(Wkv TN;N _ Y FOS
NlQ _S[kv?eV{agN N b]N'Y!j6e) _YNSv0RQQg OW^S4ls^ NM u(WVlNQ~ NM Nt^_~Nm _Yb`
Ye ]NN
NS(W1 9 6 2 t^NCSN'YO
NlQ _b1 9 5 9 t^NegrN ( NS, p 6 5 ) 0FOl
NS(WS_t^vkQJ\AS-NOO
N9T6~eNv~ OVc;N[Cg01 9 6 3 t^~Nmb_R[hQ}Yl ]QN;`NQ _Y
NGS_ -NqQ-N.Y _YSchP6R )\TNf^8f v^&T[1 9 6 1 t^LKN gHevSNP7b 1u^:WI{?eV{( ?b~-N, p 3 5 9 ) 0 0
0 03 . 5 eSi}TSvQMR_v~NmSU\
0 0'Y_SeiMRv-NV~NmW,g
N/fb`
Y0R O~T_~Nm6R^R NNSN0R7bT1uQ8^:WvmT0kl N1 9 5 6 t^(W0AS'YsQ| 0T1 9 6 0 t^0?el~Nmf[fN{ 0-NcQ N*NNT_~Nm
N Tv6R^v`l0y`l Nv_cL0NcQ?elc^ O~ T0W~ (u\W ,g0W uNb/g S['YW sN hQbRvb/g S[N[~ ir(:Ro0'Y_ N ``W,g
N N|Rv ( OYYemQASag ]NNASag QNmQASag) &T[0kvL?eRCgv ``_NS0RNv TNvb6R NN;N _ d'YWXbbe -N.YT-N~NmQV{Cg irN;`@\TWe uNDeAmvirD;`@\_NN1 9 6 3 t^^z ( ?b~-N, p 3 6 4 ) 0 y:NagagN?e kl NvL?eRCgy:NWWWWN?e0 QN?eV{eb NllQ>yvSO6R[(&T[ lQqQXce ~NmQV{CgT"N@b gCgNlQ>y N>e0R uN FO/f?e>yT NvSO6R/fOYu NegN ( ?b~-N, p p 3 0 6 , 3 1 4 , 3 1 6 , 3 4 8 ) 0 kl NsQe(W]NN|~^z?el]\O:gsQ zQ?el Q~]D~+Rte S[irD:Ro NekSbQyFU [W^yN?bN[LV gSv NNp/f(W1 9 6 5 - 1 9 6 6 t^[LN ( ?b~-N, p p . 3 7 3 - 4 1 4 ) 0 0
0 0(W1 9 5 8 1 9 6 1 t^v'YT1 9 6 6 1 9 7 0 t^veS'Yi}T g NSeS'Yi}TN_ N*N gHev-N.Y;uSO6R(W-NV]
N
YX[(W0Nt^RTt^^;u[E
NN/f N~zze01 9 5 0 t^N-NV,{ N*NNt^RvbR[kl N0W_Q 0bRR_eqQNZQ^zv>yO;NINSO6RvO'`
0v~0N
Nf}vbR/fWeT[D,g;NIN~Nmv!jN0Vdk kVR N]vqQN;NIN6R^ YNllQ>yT'YX0 Te k g Ny:_pvS` a N!P[L?eRCgS[-N.Y;u !P[k*NON0k*NS0k*Nwv~ S[NNSTRRR] !P[O~S[N[~ !P[b/g=_v\!j~v>y ON S[b/gHQv'Y!jV gON I{I{ ( k 1 9 7 7 b ) 07h Neb-NVRRR]oQba -NVQQgN\PYu(W O~v~>yO S Neb[ bN(Wkv-NVOS:g6Rv N*N wzzel g-N.Y;u_Nl g^:W YOS(W,{ N*NNt^RSU\wegvRRR]0*N wzz(Wei gQyNONTSOONkXEQ (W1 9 7 0 t^N1 9 8 4 t^_y\OaNGON ( T V E ) v>y ONTRCgvSSYNN6R^@bkXEQ0[eRCgOSv['O(WkveNSU\weg (W['O
NirirNbc^8^nfM gePw:FUT(u\OFUT'^0sQelh~Nmv1 9 9 6 t^NLuLSU\bJTcQ =\{ g1 9 5 0 T1 9 6 0 t^N]NSvbg 9ei _Ye-NV^8^+wz _'Y z^/fQN~Nm QNǖ(uN7 1 % RRR v^Nz/ec]N >yOOQScO~V g `S'Y~2 0 % NS0=_vW@xeT:_0We~[_NOv:SWNNSTOYv-N\WON0te*N~NmNT~Nmvk g\_Yv-N.Y;uT{t00We?e^ gf'YvCgR v^SU\wvS_'Yv{tR NR:NfRRCgSv~NmZPNQY0V g]NON_N_0Re4 FONSe4NTkv^
NnfM0V:NQN蕫HN%NS0Wc6R c6R Ned zsS g@bbP01 9 7 6 t^kl NSN_ -NVQQg\O:N N*NW,g~v~Nm _YNQQgR]oT6R^lh z0vk-NV1 8 % vRRR(W^QV gON (WMRT 8 5 % N
NvRRR(W^QV gON ( S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 h6 ) 0N1 9 8 5 t^w, (WTSO6R N SMRTRRRv9 9 % ( Sb(WV gTSOQ:Wv1 4 % RRR) ~N 0mx
0 ( C o o k , 1 9 9 3 [T]NOv=\vchU_) 0(W N'k~Nm g'YR]N_NNSv
0 0eSi}T Neb/fkl N[1 9 6 2 t^n{'Yv@b g~r^萄v'Y!j?elb
YT[ S Neb kl Nv^l gS/fO(uSg)R(u[P:gg d?el[vel0N1 9 6 6 t^1 0 g_ )R(u1 9 4 9 t^Neg[vNl[qQNZQ[Pv
Nn AQ gP^v1u?el~>y v^/ecSv S>mSb?el[0(W>yOI{~6R NS0Rgkv4Ne] T T]_N~~ S vQN]N_NcQS[Q~]DVYё S[~NmRM-NzQ?elvTy~NmBl0kl Ny:N~Nm;NINYΘ( ?b~-N, p p 4 1 8 , 4 2 3 , 4 2 5 S 1 9 6 6 t^ 4 gQ~VYёv-NqQch ?b~-N, p 4 1 0 ) 0eV%]N\P]\PN R
Nkl N/ec4xOW-N.Y;u:gsQv S -NV>yO;NIN~NmS uN{|
0 01uekl NvS>PT 1 9 6 6 t^-NqQ-N.Y\OQXRND,g;NIN8fsQ|vQ[ 1 9 7 2 t^-NqQ-N.YybQ4 3 NCQvbWYYTUS:gS ( ?b~-N, p 4 0 9 ) 0(Wy^b`
Y_SU\:NevND,g;NINV[SbWYYcLSfN'Yc]NSvbeu ( ?b~, p p . 5 2 3 , 5 2 7 , 5 3 0 , 5 3 1 ) 0 Nbeu Nv^~0R9ei _>eeN0vQ-N[bWYYS ёq\bWYS]YS NSTy5ulm9T uN~vSb:N-NV]NSvW@x0ybeu/fNlQ g6RR~Nmv6R^eg!jNy g6RT1u^:WR ve]NS!j_ bWYYbD Teb/g eY FOtS
N!jND,g;NINvl_6R^ "NCg~g ^:W6R^Tv^voR:g6R0 0
0 01 9 7 0 t^kl N[hQGSNeiSN uv^qQNZQvO'`?el~~_ _Y gHe0WcLN(W1 9 6 0 t^?el~Nmf[YeyfNfN{-NcQv NWYS S-N.Y;u [LL?eRCg 0WeRCg SNNS SN[~ S'Y mhQ [LO~ ~ \ W vk_>yO;NIN09hncSe 9ei _>eeNv"?eS~N6R )RmYub6R 0WeRCg6RYe1 9 5 8 t^ ( ?b~-N, p p 2 1 0 , 2 1 2 , 2 1 6 , 2 2 7 ) 0 gv/f NN]v?eV{ OYSmN]D6R_N/fYe1 9 5 8 t^ ( ?b~-N, p 2 2 8 ) 01 9 7 1 t^kl Nc6R Nve"?eck_SchcLkv0WeRCg6R vQ;NQ[/f\-N.Y{vON N>e~w~0We{t \"?e6eeQ-Nd-N.Y{ONv6eeQ W^ eYe V2 YcSsQzY RR_0We"?e0Tw?e^cQ6e/ech -N.Y~Ts^a8h[ N_ 0WeS~N 6e'Ye/eR[ N*N~[pe
N4-N.Y vQYOR_w/eM 0We"?edW[Bls^a01 9 7 2 t^*N6R^S9e:N6e NNCQNQ1u0We/eM 6e NNCQN
N-N.YT0We[JSR0v^
NQw[S^"?eB\B\S~N( ?b~, p p 4 7 5 - 4 7 6 ) 0 0We_N_0Rup;mYt N{|\W]N ONvzsvCgR0kvL?eRCg(W-N.Y0w0ST~?e^TlQ>yKNRRV gONv@b gCg0vS (WT hQV gON g~ Nv@b gCg0 0
V0-NVv~Nm9ei ( 1 9 7 8 - 2 0 0 2 ) 0
0 04 . 1 ~Nm9eivyrp
0 0kl N{k_ ~ N*Nwfv!n g \s^eccCgR0vQ~Nm?eV{;N/fQQgb`
Y1 9 6 2 t^vSN0R7b ^bklQ>y6R^ W^LV gONv>eCg)R ScR:SWRCg6R^0SN0R7bl
NOQQg~Nmb`
Y0R1 9 5 0 t^Nv4ls^0FO W0W6R^ Nvl gb`
Y0R1 9 5 0 t^N RSlVeNv6R^0hg\Q s^V Z\X( 1 9 9 2 ) ~}N-NVQQg1 9 8 0 t^Nv6R^SS0NN(u1 2 *Ncpec[Vy"N ( NT RR W0W ёDN) Lu[ N{|Cg)R ( O(uCg lCg 6evCg) vNfHes0-NV1 9 8 0 t^Nv6R^SSR:N N*N6k0,{ N6k:NLu[NTvO(uCg 6evCgTLu[RRT W0WvO(uCgvNfHes'Y'Yc,{N6k:NLu[NTTRRvlCg NSLu[RRv6evCgvNfHes'Y'Yc Lu[ W0WlCgvNfHes_N gc0,{ N6k Lu[ё"NCgvNfHes'Y'Yc Lu[ W0WlCgvNfHesfc0FO;`SO W0WNCg6R^SSv[eNT RRvNfHesvc\ q_T"NlCgv6R^SSS\eq_T"NO(uT6evCgv6R^SS01ueLu[NCgv~TNfHescpeN1 9 7 9 t^v0 . 3 8 4 XR0R1 9 8 7 t^v0 . 6 4 2 -NVQQgvFUNS z^_Ne T gN0 . 4 5 5 XR0R0 . 6 4 5 09hnchg\QTZ\X ( Y a n g , 2 0 0 1 , c h . 1 6 ) vNCg~Nmf[!jW FUNS z^S fNR] z^0 -NVQQgR]4ls^vc O uNRc0te*N8 0 t^N-NVQQgNGW w[6eeQt^GWXs9 % ( Y a n g , W a n g , a n d W i l l s , 1 9 9 2 ) 0 0
0 0v:SWRCg6R^S-N.YTw~?e^v"?esQ| ]VNkvL?eRCg0egz6eTV gON)Rmv?e^6eeQOnc N[vRMR(W-N.YTw~?e^KNRR0(Wv:SWRCgve g V[pevw?e^6eeQ
NN~-N.Y?e^ (W_ g V[kOvw?e^6eeQ
NN~-N.Y?e^0Nkl NeN
N Tv/f -N.Y[T~?e^[LB\B\"?eS~N0 Ny-NV_"?eT;NINN*No z-NQs [:N1 9 9 0 t^N-NV9eicONcRR0(WNLuLv.^R N y"?eT;NINb0We?e^vz6ey{|T_6e:ggN-N.Y?e^vz6ey{|T_6e:ggRy _ ( Q i a n a n d R o l a n d , 1 9 9 8 , Q i a n a n d W e i n g a s t , 1 9 9 7 v"?eT;NINTOV-N.YCgWvT?e^N0We?e^v"?esQ|b_bfv[k ( Z h u r a v s k a y a , 1 9 9 8 T Q i a n , 1 9 9 9 ) 0 R0WN-NVTOWe9ei~Hev]+R0FO/fbN
N^0Ov:SWRCgT"?eT;NIN[~NmSU\v!.s0HQ [rRN^:Wv^XN0WeV gONvWeRR ( hT, 1 9 9 9 , UO, 1 9 9 7 , P 2 0 6 ) 0bcS v:SWRCg~bNkvL?eRCgOWveb V ;xNhQV~ N^:Wvb_b b ( L a r d y , 1 9 9 8 a P 2 0 4 ) N}lfLN:NOfN NpvQ!k -NVv"?eT;NINNVv"?eT;NINKN g]+Rg'Y0N1 9 5 4 t^ _Y uHev7bM|6R^g'Y0WP6RNRRRTNRD,gv1uAmR0=\{яeg N6R^ gN9ei (W'YW^AQl g8lENE\OOCgvylkt^fbcfOO0FO/f (W-NVv'YW^-NNQQgegvylk
N
NVv~aSylv0WMO0(W-NV yl_{kS_0W8lENE\l/eN_YvP[sYeQf[9TpN?bN
Nwm
NQO(uVnS6R v}lf\O zf0VnS
NQO(u
Nwm6R v}lf\O zf0 0
0 0eQ9eieNe -NVN gS'Yc]NST!jNV{euv_'YYO0W (W-NV O~v~LNv6eeQkhf(W:ONyNNCgT^:WagN N N6q g!jNSD,g;NINV[RRR] gHe!j_vzz FO/fS_T _Y[v9eie yV{euv\oR]~=\N0 0
0 0FO-NVNNwvvSU\~He
NNN/fV:N!jNvD,g;NIN]NS!j_v\oR e,g0/n0S~n0WS闌TvQN NNV[0N[v>yO_N:Ne!jNV{eucONzz0/n0S~nTvQNetQ]NSD,g;NIN~NmcONRR[WQS]NSe!j_vMQ9D y!j_)R(uS~NmT
NS~NmNGW w[6eeQv>fW]_ QSRR[W6RbTbcSD,g[WY0egS~nT/nvNSFU&^egNRD,g0ON[b06R^wTD,g N[e-NV!jNevD,g;NIN]NS!j_gvQ0-NV?e^_N ga0Wf[`NS~nT/nv~ OY ~Nmyr:Seu/f[S~nTvQND,g;NINV[QSR]:ST1u8f:SvvcNHe0Nyr:S>fW0WQ\NVsQzTvQN8fXW bvNf9(u0YVvcbDvyNCg)R(Wyr:SQk(W NSVvvQN0W:SS0R}Y_YvOb0OgqhgvD,gTRRR]t ( Y a n g , 1 9 9 9 , _NS a c h s a n d Y a n g , 2 0 0 1 ,{1 6 z) NShgTvc[Nt ( Y a n g a n d N g , 1 9 9 5 , _N S a c h s a n d Y a n g , 2 0 0 1 , ,{8 z) hfYVON[ g:_poRRRONbNNvON[bcVS~ NSV0FOv0R 2 0 N~+g -NVvR]QST1u8f:SNN?e^cvON:N;N ?e^N0W4YvN)R(u[0WeDnvWe :_YFU(WP[ gPQ\NTNVNS OYVvcbD6R^(uegObYVON[vwNCgvR
NEQRS%c0 0
0 0v9eieNwQ gSgTkl Nv>yO;NINv$N*NW,gyrp?elCgRv NZQWeTV gONv/eM0WMO09hncb ( L a r d y , 1 9 9 8 ) ve.sU_ (W9eieN cgqNQTǖ]4ls^0ǖ]k06e0RёDnv4ls^Tk V g(Wib _0 (W g'Yvyr:Sm3W V gONc6RW~Nm0FO/f
N TNT_v6R^ -NVv
N Tv?e^:ggS0We?e^KN(W~Nm
N gvS_opvzN0 y6R^vyr_/f6R^SvV[:gO;NINTP% ~NmSU\N6q/fyrCg6B\e_)RvvN(0 0
0 0-NVv^:W[T9ei gyr_/f:ON[?ey^Tll hf6R^SvV[:gO;NIN ~l6B\vGPlQNmyTsWsvP%0bN\(W_eRg:ON[?ey^v`Q N^:W[T9eivyr_0 0
0 0;`~ N N -NV1 9 8 0 NT1 9 9 0 t^NNNwvvX~He;NR_Re[=_vwYSU\4ls^ ( sSN~pvkl NeNb`
Yv'`() T!jNevQS[TW]NS!j_ve:gO v>yO;NIN^:W~Nm/fkvL?eRCgTV gONN[S~nT/neSU\!j_!jNv N*NmTSO0*NaIN
N v>yO;NIN^:W~Nm
N TNpQ
0 0[-NV9eivwYagNTcRRv bNsQe-NV9eivY[p0
0 0HQ NN-NVN[[-NVSU\~He0O (KQeT ( S a c h s a n d W o o , 1 9 9 9 ) cQ -NVvX~Hev^
NkvQN NN~NmX~He}Y N[
N (WSv NASt^ WeRR[W6RbT QSXV{eu NNk*N^:W~Nm^8^ 0WX 1 9 8 6 1 9 9 4 t^ c-pNRs^Nte_ -NVt^^NGWG D P Xs(W5 . 6 6 . 8 % KN vQN NNV[(W1 9 6 5 1 9 9 0 t^fve_NhsQ T7hufv c-pNRs^Nte_vt^^NGWG D P Xs Sb/n 5 . 8 V 7 . 4 eRaW7 . 4 S~n 6 . 3 pS<\ 4 . 7 legN 4 . 5 lV 4 . 6 0SY (W-NVTetQ]NS~NmSO YS~nKN NGW w[6eeQ]N(WR'Y0 0
0 0-NVv[e~_N0O w[Xs0b ( L a r d y , 1 9 9 8 ) cQ [eDe\0OXs1 2 % 0 NN-NVf[ OYW~ (
0~Nmf[mo`b 01 9 9 9 t^5 g1 5 e 1 Hr) :N [eDe0OXs2 3 % 0b ( L a r d y , 1 9 9 8 ) _NcON-NV?e^EeawsQeV gLOW^TV gON"RrQDvnc0 0